Frankly, with some notable exceptions, 2011 was a disappointing year for music. Many of my favorite bands released albums, some of which were good and are mentioned below, others of which were not bad by still unacceptably mediocre (e.g., Killing Time by Bayside or Going Out In Style by Dropkick Murphys) while a few (I’m With You by the Red Hot Chili Peppers and Mylo Xyloto by Coldplay) were just awful and made me question humanity. Given all that, I found it hard to pick 10 albums worthy of appearing on the list. But I endured.
Note: as always, compilation albums and live albums are not included.
1. Protest the Hero | Scurrilous
The album of the year by a wide margin. Perhaps destined to be the album of the decade. It is so good that at one time or another I declared three separate songs (‘C’est la Vie,’ ‘Hair Trigger’ and ‘Dunsel’) to be the song of the year, with the last securing the honor. And then some. ‘Dunsel’ just flat rules my world right now; it makes me want jump around the room headbanging with no hair and playing air-guitar. Do me a favor and watch the ‘C’est la Vie’ video and feast your eyes on the awesomeness of them rocking while sitting down. The album rocks. Buy. Listen. Repeat. If you don’t love this almost-out-of-control-but-not-quite, heavy-yet-melodic, fret-shredding Canadian rock fest, I will slap you. Favorite tracks: ‘C’est la Vie,’ ‘Hair Trigger,’ ‘Dunsel,’ and ‘Moonlight.’
2. Foo Fighers | Wasting Light
A solid second place for Dave Grohl and company despite its terrible album cover. In fact, in most years, ‘Wasting Light’ would be making a push at album of the year. As I have noted in past posts, it also marked the moment the Foo Fighters passed Nirvana in my mind. Nirvana has not and most likely will not be passed in cultural significance, but in general musical quality and diversity, the Foo Fighters are simply a better band. Favorite tracks: ‘Rope,’ ‘Dear Rosemary,’ and ‘Arlandria.’
3. The Book of Mormon | Soundtrack
The Book of Mormon would be awesome by virtue of being written by Trey and Matt by being exceptionally creative and satirical. But, beyond all that, it is musically really good. I mean, surprisingly good. For a strictly musical theater point of view, it is higher quality than, say, Chicago. Plus it is, you know, really funny. Favorite tracks: ‘Hello!,’ ‘All-American Prophet,’ and ‘Man up.’
4. Opeth | Heritage
I’ve said it before and I will say it again: I love where Opeth is going. Their early albums were instrumentally wonderful, but the heavy metal vocals were just distracting. I don’t mind the occasional growls, but Mikael Åkerfeldt may have the best voice in the world right now and the more he uses it the better. Heritage continues where Watershed left off, mixing classic Scandinavian metal with more prog, alternative sensibilities. It is easy to understand why Åkerfeldt is good friends with Steven Wilson of Porcupine Tree. Favorite tracks: ‘The Devil’s Orchard,’ ‘Slither.’
5. Emery | We Do What We Want
I am a huge fan of Emery, whose sometimes heavy and sometimes quiet and melodic sound and thoughtful lyrics (which, while not over the top, are still clearly Christian in sentiment) combine to make them one of the best bands going. Unfortunately, We Do What We Want is something of a step back after the fantastic EP/LP While Broken Hearts Prevail/In Shallow Seas We Sail dual release in 2009. It has some solid songs, but ends on a far too quiet, dare I say ‘wussy’ note. However, there is enough good to warrant a spot on the Top Ten. Favorite tracks: ‘I’m Not Here For the Rage I’m Here For the Revenge’ and ‘The Cheval Glass.’
6. Mastodon | The Hunter
By now, we all know what to expect from Mastodon: high-quality, intelligent, progressive metal. Which always produces a mental image of pillaging vikings (but perhaps that is due to Brent Hinds’ flaming red beard). The Hunter is not a concept album like their earlier work albums, but it still has the feel of a norse epic. And you can just assume that a Mastodon title track will rock. Favorite tracks: ‘Black Tongue,’ ‘Stargasm,’ and ‘The Hunter.’
7. In Flames | Sounds of a Playground Falling
As with their fellow Swedes, Opeth, I have gladly embraced the fact each successive In Flames album is more melodic with more clean vocals. However, the departure of founding member Jesper Strömblad left me fearing that Sounds of a Playground Falling would constitute a huge step back for the band. I am happy to report my fear was unfounded. While the album is not as good as the band’s prior four albums, it is still quite good. Strömblad’s touch will be missed, but In Flames is still one of the best groups in the world. Favorite tracks: ‘All For Me,’ ‘Deliver Us,’
8. Taking Back Sunday | Taking Back Sunday
Taking Back Sunday is the musical equivalent of a Donald Driver: never flashy and always overshadowed by teammates, but always there, always consistent, and, when you look back on it, the proud owner of a pretty damn good career. Taking Back Sunday have never released a truly great album, but you can always count on them for a reasonable level of quality. Favorite tracks: ‘Faith (When I Let You Down’ and ‘It Doesn’t Feel a Thing Like Falling.’
9. Funeral For a Friend | Welcome Home Armageddon
A solid album, and a definite improvement over their last few LPs. The problem is the best two songs on Welcome Home Armageddon (‘Sixteen’ and ‘Damned If You Do, Dead If You Don’t') were on last year’s Young And Powerless EP which was a 2010 Top Ten Album. I feel bad double dipping but 2011 was just that weak.
10. Beastie Boys | Hot Sauce Committee Part Two
‘Lee Majors Come Again’ may be my favorite Beastie song ever. It alone justifies being in the List.